Serotonin 101: Why 5-HTP Does not Work for You


The link between serotonin and depression has long been established and the most common anti-depressant drugs work through boosting serotonin levels. However, these Selective Serotonin Re-uptake Inhibitors (SSRIs) are also notorious for causing a wide range of side effects, which include increased risk of suicide, apathy and sexual dyfunction.

Therefore, with rates of depression rising and doctors showing no interest in refining the usage of these anti-depressants, it is no surprise that a naturopathic alternative to these drugs would garner such attention. And they do. Step forward 5-HTP, an amino acid touted by some as the key to curing depression naturally and derided by others as useless.

So what does 5-HTP do? We will get to that. But first, a primer on serotonin. There are seven different types of serotonin (22 sub-types that have been discovered so far), although we will refer to all types as ‘serotonin’ for the purposes of this article. Serotonin is manufactured in the midbrain by the raphe nuclei*, itself stimulated into doing so by the neighbouring tectum. This gland itself increases it’s action in line with the levels of sunlight (yes, sun exposure and serotonin production are linked). Serotonin is considered a inhibitory (calming) neurotransmitter. Scientifically speaking, serotonin is actually an excitatory neurotransmitter, but it operates primarily on inhibitory pathways and it’s effects are generally calming and mood-enhancing. I refer to it in talks and in clinic as inhibitory.

Symptoms and signs that your serotonin pathway is not functioning effectively include:
– low mood
– little enjoyment from life
– reduced desire to socialise
– inner rage/anger
– difficulty reaching deep sleep and staying there
– feeling better and sleeping better in summer or when exposed to more intense sunshine

You can’t supplement with serotonin as it will not cross the blood-brain barrier. Instead, the nutritional approach to supporting levels of this important neurotransmitter revolve around the provision of it’s precursors. This means taking tryptophan or hydroxytryptophan (5-HTP), When you take 5-HTP, the standard narrative tells us that it crosses the blood-brain barrier and then the brain converts it

This is what really happens, broken into three key points:
- 1. Transport into the brain. This is achieved by the actions of LNAA (Large Neutral Amino Acid) transporter, which has the job of shuttling certain amino acids from blood to brain. It isn’t just 5-HTP that depends on this transporter; so to does taurine, as well as the branched chain amino acids (leucine, isoleucine and valine). This is relevant because, for full theurapeutic effect to occur following 5-HTP administration, you need to ensure that there is no too much competition at the LNAA transporter. If you have just eating a protein-rich meal, there will be many other amino acids vying for use of this shuttle and very little 5-HTP will make it across the border. Equally, insulin sequesters the branched chain amino acids out of the blood stream and into muscle cells. Exercise does the same. The more drained the muscles are and the more insulin there is, the less competition there is for 5-HTP to get into the brain. The opposite is also true; if you never exercise, you will compromise the transport of 5-HTP through the blood-brain barrier. If your insulin levels are particularly low (eg. very low calorie diets, very low carb diets), the same rules. I will repeat that as it is particularly important: very-low carbohydrate diets can effect your body’s ability to transport serotonin precursors into the brain.
– 2. Conversion of 5-HTP into serotonin. The conversion of the precursor into the target neurotransmitter is done through a process called methylation. This crucial chemical reaction occurs all over the body and is particularly noticeable at the brain, liver, immune system plays a huge role in maintaining cardiovascular health. It requires an ongoing supply of B6, B12, folic acid and methyl donors (found in foods such as onions and garlic and in supplements like TMG, DMAE and SAMe). The conversion of 5-HTP to serotonin is also dependent on sufficient magnesium, a mineral that almost every Londoner I see is deficient in.
– 3. Activation of the receptor. So your 5-HTP has now moved successfully over the blood-brain barrier, you have methylated it into serotonin. So far, so good. But the final, all-important step is for the serotonin molecule to bind with it’s receptor sites. This may happen just fine, but often it does not; the most common cause of this is hormonal imbalance. Both testosterone and estrogen are hugely important to maintain neural sensitivity to serotonin, especially in the frontal lobes. Thyroid hormones are also crucial. Take home message here: if you haven’t measured your hormones, you are likely wasting your time by playing with your neurotransmitter levels. However, it’s worth noting that inherent insensitivity can also occur. This is common after the use of anti-depressant drugs like SSRIs or mirtazepine. However, years of letting your blood-sugar levels swing wildly can also cause this (through fluctuations in insulin and therefore wild swings in the amount of 5-HTP crossing the blood-brain barrier).

Beyond these 3 crucial steps, there are occasions sensitivity of the receptor is just fine, but the synaptic breakdown of serotonin is occurring too quickly. In such cases, use of natural MAOIs (mono amino oxidase inhibitors) like St Johns Wort can be tremendously helpful. I notice this is particularly likely to help if an individual is noticing low action in just the dopamine and serotonin pathways. But I digress.

In any case, if you are on the Atkins diet, supplementing 5-HTP with food, have not tested your ability to methylate and have previously used anti-depressant drugs, you chances of effecting your serotonin pathways with a 5-HTP supplement are virtually zero. There are a number of factors that must be taken into account for the amino acid to be effective and, many times, these factors are ignored. This explains why 5-HTP does nothing for so many people, even though their serotonin pathway may be in desperate need of support.

Equally, there exists a sizeable minority at the opposite end of the spectrum, who take 5-HTP and it boosts their serotonin levels very effectively to the point that they get a negative response (normally disturbed sleep). This is because they didn’t actually need any more serotonin and, in excess, this neurotransmitter will enhance the secretion of ACTH, the hormone that stimulates the adrenal glands into action. While this can be very helpful for some individuals if it occurs in the morning, it can cause issues if it occurs before bedtime. This is especially true of any individual with adrenal problems and, indeed, anyone who notices insomnia after taking 5-HTP at night should assess their adrenal function.

At this point, it should be clear that it is ridiculous to call 5-HTP good or bad, effective or useless. Like many nutrients, it’s effect is dependent on the method of use and the individual biochemistry of the user. I use it regularly in the clinic, often with great results, but only after establishing whether there is an actually a requirement to support the serotonin pathway and assessing the individuals nutrient status, hormonal balance, methylation ability and always bearing in mind inherent neural sensitivity. Bottom line: 5-HTP works, but there is much more to it than swallowing 100mg and expecting to feel better.

*it’s also made in the intestines, but this article is focusing on neural serotonin.